Agenda and draft minutes

Executive Member for Adult Social Care, Public Health, Public Protection and Digital Inclusion - Thursday 20th October, 2022 10.00 am

Venue: Oberhausen room

Contact: Susie Blood 

Items
No. Item

22/3

Approval of the framework for calculating the level of civil penalty charge in relation to breaches of the Tenant Fees Act 2019 and relevant Letting Agency legislation pdf icon PDF 670 KB

Minutes:

The Director of Adult Social Care and Health Integration submitted a report, the purpose of which was to seek approval for the framework to calculate the financial penalty charges for breaches of relevant letting agency legislation by landlords, letting agents and property management companies.

 

The report advised that the ability to issue financial penalty charges was an alternative to prosecution and was in accordance with Public Protection Regulatory Services Enforcement Policy and follows Tenant Fees Act Statutory Guidance for enforcement authorities.

 

The framework has been developed in line with national guidance however, the method for calculating the financial penalty charge was not prescribed in law or by Government. It lies with local authorities to develop their own framework.

 

The implications of the recommendation(s) have been considered by the appropriate officers of the Council and were set out in the main body of the report. This report falls within the Terms of Reference of this Committee as the policies proposed will impact on all wards within the Borough and represents a change in the policy on the approach of enforcement. 

 

OPTIONS

Other potential decision(s) and why these have not been recommended

 

1.     Do not introduce a civil penalty charge. If this is not introduced there would be no change to current enforcement practices in that prosecution action would be taken for offences, where appropriate. This is a time consuming process for officers and Legal Services, it can take many months or years to achieve an outcome and does not always achieve the desired results in terms of level of penalty or a deterrent.

 

2.     The use of civil penalties offers a reduced cost enforcement option that will act as an immediate and more effective deterrent.  This enforcement tool will address the poor management of properties and unfair business practices in the private rented sector and drive up standards and levels of compliance. The framework for calculating the level of charge will provide transparency and consistency in this approach.

 

ORDERED

 

1.     That the Executive approves the framework for calculating the civil penalty charges in relation to the Act and associated legislation.  

 

REASONS

The decisions were supported by the following reasons:

 

1.     Using a civil penalty charge instead of prosecution is considered to deal more effectively with breaches of law, to encourage compliance, drive up standards in private rented accommodation and deter unfair practices. It also provides an alternative way for the Council to deal with criminal, rogue and irresponsible landlords, letting agents and property management companies.

 

2.     The Civil penalty charge can be up to £5,000 for first breaches in respect of prohibited payments, non-publication of lettings fees, transparency issues in relation to membership of redress and client money protection schemes, and up to £30,000 for subsequent breaches or for other offences including non-membership of redress or client money protection schemes.  Establishing a means for calculating the level of penalty is designed to ensure transparency, consistency and fairness. 

 

 

3.     The use of civil penalties will not remove the Council’s ability to take  ...  view the full minutes text for item 22/3

22/4

Approval of the framework for calculating the level of civil penalty charge for breaches of landlord duties under private sector housing laws pdf icon PDF 649 KB

Minutes:

The Director of Adult social care and health integration submitted a report that sought approval for a framework for calculating financial penalty charges for offences committed by persons who have duties under housing laws, which includes landlords, lettings agents, managing agents and license holders. The use of penalty charges has been brought into effect under the provisions of the Housing and Planning Act 2016 and the Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector (England) Regulations 2020. The ability to issue financial penalty charges is an alternative to prosecution, in accordance with the Public Protection Regulatory Services Enforcement Policy.

 

The report advised that where conditions in a rented property do not meet legal standards or there is a failure to meet statutory obligations such as with regard to the management of properties, the Council (Public Protection Service) has power to serve enforcement notices to require remedial action, including physical improvement to properties, better management of shared accommodation or to invoke prohibitions on the use of properties.  The Housing and Planning Act 2016 amendments the primary housing legislation (the Housing Act 2004) to enable local authorities as the enforcing authority under the housing laws to impose a financial penalty as an alternative to prosecution for certain offences.  Similarly, penalty charges imposed under the Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector (England) Regulations 2020 will be determined using the framework approved for civil penalty charges.    

 

The method for calculating the financial penalty charges was not prescribed in law or by Government and it lies with local authorities to develop their own framework.

 

The implications of the recommendation(s) have been considered by the appropriate officers of the Council and are set out in the main body of the report. This report falls within the Terms of Reference of this Committee as the policies proposed will impact on all wards within the Borough and represents a change in the policy on the approach housing enforcement.

 

OPTIONS

Other potential decision(s) and why these have not been recommended

 

1.     Do not introduce civil penalty charges. If they are not introduced there would be no change to current enforcement practices in that prosecution action would be taken for offences, where appropriate. This is time consuming process for officers and Legal Services, it can take many months or years to achieve an outcome and does not always achieve the desired results in terms of level of penalty or a deterrent.

 

2.     The use of civil penalties offers a reduced cost enforcement option that will act as an immediate and more effective deterrent.  This enforcement tool will address the poor management of properties in the private rented sector and drive up standards and levels of compliance. The framework for calculating the level of charge will provide transparency and consistency in this approach.

 

ORDERED

 

That Executive approves the framework for calculating the civil penalty charges in relation to housing offences.

 

REASONS

The decisions were supported by the following reasons:

 

3.     The Housing and Planning Act 2016 provides Local Authorities  ...  view the full minutes text for item 22/4

The decision(s) will come into force after five working days following the day the decision(s) was published unless the decision becomes subject to the call in procedures.